[Editor’s note: Are you fan of all things ID4? Don’t miss the Independence Day Overview, our downloadable commentary on the movie. Get it now!]
Matt Belinkie: Independence Day seems curiously sticky in our cultural memory. It arrived twenty years ago this weekend, emerging from a fiery cloud of hype. The second-highest grossing movie of the summer was Twister, and when’s the last time you saw a meme from that one?
Two years later came Armageddon, which was a similarly epic save-the-world story with an a-list cast. It has a 6.6 on IMDB, compared to Independence Day’s 6.9. That’s basically the same. And yet my perception is that Independence Day gets WAY more love. What’s the special sauce here?
I feel like calling something a b-movie today has nothing to do with budget. B-movieness is about an embrace of genre tropes and a loose approach to plotting. I’m thinking of the President of the United States getting in a jet to personal attack the aliens converging on Area 51.
Ryan Sheely: I think the b-movieness of ID4 is really interesting, but I think it isn’t just a straight b-movie. I’d rather think of it as a “neo- b-movie,” which I’ll describe as a “b-movie story, characters, and dialogue with a-list actors and effects.”
The movie has so many quotable lines. “Welcome to Earth,” “What do you want us to do? DIE,” and the entire climactic “Today we celebrate our Independence Day” monologue. They aren’t much on paper, but they work because of the performances.
Now imagine the “JULY 4” title wasn’t there. Nothing changes about the plot, but the sad death scene would be followed immediately by another sad scene, with Jeff Goldblum stumbling around drunk. Putting that title in radically changes our mindset. We know before the characters do that things are about to change. Some might call that needless signposting, but I think that kind of simplicity is what makes this movie work. A movie that was trying to be “better” would say, “Wait, does it make sense that hundreds of fighter jets and pilots are just sitting around at Area 51?” But ID4 wants to keep things simple, so Area 51 becomes the one and only spot that the United States launches its counterattack from.
Also, you’ve got the “We will not go quietly into the night” monologue, which is basically our generation’s St. Crispin’s Day speech. I will brook no disagreement on this subject.
I think novelty is also a part of this. I don’t know if this was explicitly part of the marketing, but I remember going into ID4 hearing that this was bigger and more awesome than anything that had come before, and the elements of execution that we’ve talked about actually made it meet those overheated expectations (at least for a particular subset of viewers, which includes most of us). The other film from our youth that I remember being hyped as being “bigger and more awesome than any movie to date” that also delivered is Jurassic Park, which I also loved when it was out.
Belinkie: And what about the famous (infamous?) Presidential speech? Is it a legitimately good speech? I got to say, the idea that “you will once again be fighting for our freedom… from annihilation” seems like a strained comparison at best. And the idea that mankind should now put aside its petty differences against a common enemy seems pretty pedestrian.
It’s interesting that until this point in the movie, we see very little of what’s going on outside the United States. All the destruction we see is American cities. But at this very late stage, we get a montage showing an international group of fighters all unquestioningly accepting American leadership. That’s immediately followed up by this speech, which basically says “Y’all going to be celebrating the 4th of July from now on.” For all intents and purposes, the Earth is the United States.
Sheely: Oh man, I wonder if there is a Brexit plot line, where he UK leaves the global anti-Alien alliance and pays for it. Doesn’t the trailer have parts of London blowing up?
Belinkie: I would not be surprised if someone (Russia, I’m looking at you) tries to cut a deal with the aliens, rather than go along with the United States’ attack plan. We may have to re-enter this tank after the aliens invade this weekend, to discuss how the politics of global annihilation have changed in an age when that idea seems less like harmless fun.
Want to hear a lot more overthinking of ID4? Check out our Independence Day Overview! It’s a full-length commentary track that will fill you with both hegemonic discourse and patriotic pride.